People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This place is a family tradition going back many, many years. It's definitely an Ohio thing, baked crust and sauce THEN cold cheese added after the fact. However, by the time you get it home, it has melted into absolute perfection. The people who run it know what they're doing. ”
“ Great little pizza shop. Service was great. I haven’t had the pizza in a long time. But man still taste the same. Best part is you can get it by the slice. But had to go with the 6 cut for me. ”
“ I literally cannot say enough deliciously, wonderful things about this pizza!!! I will move heaven and earth to seek out this magical delight. Had it tonight for the first time in years and I cried like a baby!!! Please NEVER stop making this delicacy... ”
“ A valley classic! This one is my favorite DiCarlos too, the pizza is always perfect ”
“ Always a great experience from start to finish. Today was no exception! Driving from Pittsburgh to Columbus and knew I had to stop in. Pizza is awesome as always! And Jake was great company while I waited! ”
“ So, we are not from here and when we heard about Pittsburg style pizza, we were skeptical. I mean, who wants cold cheese on pizza? But we were pleasantly surprised. The crust and the sauce were really the superstars of this pizza. Crispy and chewy crust, delicious sauce. We ordered a full sheet and took it back to our hotel and by the time we got back, the cheese was a little melty, but honestly, we didnt hate it. The flavor of cheese is still there. We were surprised that toppings weren't really a thing. We got pepperoni and there were a few, but again, its not this style. If you like crust and sauce as the main part of pizza, this is for you. Give it a go! ”
“ There was 1 gentleman working, and he was awesome at getting our food out in a timely manner. ”
“ I wish I could’ve caught the mans name but he was amazing. My family and I came up from Florida to visit family in the area, and I think all of us can agree the food was outstanding. I didn’t snap a picture of the pizza or the little deep dish he made us and the hot wings, but the calzone was heavenly. Definitely stopping by again when we come up ”
Menu
House
US$1.25Cheesy Bread
US$4.99Buffalo
US$8.99Steak
US$8.99Italian
US$8.99
About
DiCarlo's Pizza - St Clairsville
Welcome to DiCarlo's Pizza - St Clairsville, a cherished gem nestled at 117 W Main St, St Clairsville, OH 43950. Here, pizza is more than just food; it’s a tradition that spans generations. With a rich history and unwavering commitment to flavor, this local eatery captivates the hearts and palates of its customers.
Step inside and enjoy the iconic baked crust that sets DiCarlo's apart—a harmonious blend of crispy and chewy, adorned with their unique sauce. Once out of the oven, the cold cheese is delicately draped atop, melting into an epitome of cheesy perfection by the time you reach your destination. The nostalgia of this preparation is palpable, much like customer Amy, who fondly recalls her family tradition surrounding DiCarlo's, emphasizing that "the people who run it know what they're doing."
But the charm doesn’t stop there. Beyond the pizza, DiCarlo's offers an array of fresh salads and hearty sandwiches. Salads like the House and Antipasto are perfect for those seeking a lighter option, while sandwiches such as the Italian and Steak promise to satisfy a more robust appetite, all priced reasonably to ensure everyone can indulge.
For those craving wings, the boneless variety at $12.99 for a pound is another delightful option that complements your pizza perfectly. And let’s not forget the option to grab a slice on the go—this casual approach keeps diners coming back, just as Warren Roscoe noted about the shop's wonderful service and nostalgia-inducing flavor.
Every visit to DiCarlo's feels personal. It’s not just about ordering food; you’re welcomed into a community where flavors have been perfected over time. As Dina Wonn proclaimed, this pizza is a "magical delight" that evokes deep emotions, expressing a longing to cherish this culinary treasure forever. Whether you’re a local or a traveler, make sure to stop by—every bite brings joy and a slice of history wrapped in warm, cheesy goodness.
For those venturing through, don't hesitate to call them at +1 740-449-2195 to place an order or inquire about their offerings. Experience the delightful embrace of DiCarlo's Pizza, where every visit is a celebration of taste and tradition!
Book a table